[BGBM-Logo] Lichen determination keys
- neotropical Parmotrema -
[BGBM-Foto klein]


MASON HALE's key to Parmotrema, revised edition:
key to wide-lobed parmelioid species occurring in Tropical America
(genera Canomaculina, Parmotrema, Rimelia, Rimeliella)

by H. Sipman; last update 28 October 2005

This is an update for an unpublished key which Mason HALE distributed to several lichenologists in the late seventies. I have used it until it got dog-ears and became irreadible. Therefore I have made a new, updated version. Following the intention of Mason, it is placed on the Internet for general use. Adriano Spielman provided useful suggestions.


1a    Thallus with isidia or dactyles (which may become pustulate or 
      be mixed with soredia)                                        2
1b    Thallus with soredia; soralia linear or round to diffuse, 
      occasionally produced on pustules; no isidial initials 
      present                                                      51
1c    Thallus without isidia or soredia                           121

2a    Cilia completely lacking around lobe tips and in lobe axils   3
2b    Cilia well developed around lobe tips to quite sparse and 
      present only in lobe axils                                   14

3a    Medulla yellow or pale yellow orange                          4
3b    Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decaying plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                        6

4a    Isidia slender, dense, not pustular, not hollow; medulla K-, C+ 
      red (gyrophoric acid and entothein); large, leathery plants, 
      similar to P. tinctorum; widespread
                     P. endosulphureum (Hillm.) Hale (Hale 1965: 251)
4b    Isidia coarse, pustular, hollow; medulla K+ yellow turning red 
      or C+ red (salazinic or gyrophoric acid)                      5

5a    Medulla K+ yellow turning red, C- (salazinic acid); Venezuelan 
      Andes                  P. enteroxanthum Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 434)
5b    Medulla K+ yellow, C+ red (gyrophoric acid); southern Brazil 
      (synonymized with P. flavomedullosum)   Parmelia elabens Kurok.

6a    Isidia coarse, dactyliform or pustular or becoming fatiscent
      -coralloid                                                    7
6b    Isidia thin, cylindrical, simple to sparsely branched, laminal
                                                                   10

7a    Isidia dactyliform                                            8
7b    Isidia pustular or becoming fatiscent-coralloid               9

8a    Unidentified fatty acid present; conidia unknown; Argentina
                                    P. alidactylatum Estrabou & Adler
8b    Caperatic and unidentified aliphatic acids present; conidia 
      sublageniform or weakly bifusiform, 5-7.5 mu long; SE Brazil 
      (Rio Grande do Sul)                         P. dactylosum Fleig
8c    Norlobaridon and loxodic acid present; conidia sublageniform, 
      6 mu long; SE Brazil (Rio Grande do Sul)     P. dissimile Fleig

9a    Isidia becoming fatiscent-coralloid, mostly marginal; 
      protocetraric acid present; laciniae developing into large, 
      coralloid (Stereocaulon-like) clusters
                        P. fasciculatum (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 252)
9b    Isidia pustular; protocetraric acid present; orange yellow 
      pigment near lower surface (skyrin); Parana
                                                 P. gibberosum Kurok.

10a   Medulla C+ red (lecanoric acid); widespread and common
                            P. tinctorum (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 264)
10b   Medulla C-                                                   11

11a   Medulla K+ yellow turning red (norstictic acid) (when strongly 
      applanate and with rhizoid initials near the lobe tips, cf. 
      Parmotremopsis antillensis (Nyl.) Elix & Hale)  P. guyanum Hale
11b   Medulla K- or K+ slowly yellowish to brownish (protocetraric 
      acid or fatty acids)                                         12

12a   Thallus yellowish green (usnic acid present in cortex; proto-
      cetraric acid)     P. conformatum (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 270)
12b   Thallus mineral greenish grey to white (atranorin present in
      cortex)                                                      13 

13a   Protocetraric acid present; corticolous at higher elevations in 
      Caribbean region     P. peralbidum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 257)
13b   Aliphatic acids as in P. praesorediosum present; Brazil 
      (Paraná), saxicolous                     P. praeisidiosum Fleig

14a (2) Medulla yellow to orange throughout                        15
14b   Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decaying plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                       18

15a   Medulla deep yellow (vulpinic acid); isidia fine, cylindrical; 
      cortex often cracked, revealing the pigment; widespread in the 
      lowlands            P. sulphuratum (Nees) Hale (Hale 1965: 312)
15b   Medulla pale yellow to orange (no vulpinic acid)             16

16a   Medulla pale yellow orange, K+ yellow turning red (salazinic 
      acid); isidia very coarse, tall; Venezuelan Andes, 2100 m, on 
      rock                                      P. enteroxanthum Hale
16b   Medulla orange to ochraceous, K+ dark purple (pigment!) or K-; 
      corticolous                                                  17

17a   Thallus isidiate; isidia fragile, sometimes ciliate, coralloid-
      branched and brown-tipped; margins with flaking cortex; medulla 
      completely pigmented, C-, KC- (pigment only); Amazonia, Guianas
                         P. aurantiacoparvum Sipman (Mycotaxon 44: 4)
      (Acc. to Kurokawa & Moon (1998) identical with next species)
17b   Thallus coarsely sorediate or isidiate-sorediate, with laminal 
      and submarginal soralia; unpigmented medulla C-, KC+ rose 
      (alectoronic acid); southern Brazil
                     P. hypomiltoides (Vain.) Kurok. (Hale 1965: 293)

18a (14) Thallus yellowish green (usnic acid dominant in cortex)   19
18b   Thallus mineral greenish grey to white (atranorin dominant in 
      cortex)                                                      23

19a   Medulla P-, C+ rose (gyrophoric acid) or C- (fatty acid); 
      Caribbean, Mexico, USA, southern Brazil
                      P. xanthinum (Müll. Arg.) Hale (Hale 1965: 275)
      (incl. P. madagascariaceum (Hue) Hale (Hale 1965: 275); 
      Parmelia aberrans (Vain.) Des Abb. (Hale 1965: 269)
19b   Medulla P+ orange or red, C-                                 20

20a   Medulla K- or K+ slowly yellowish to brownish (protocetraric 
      acid)                                                        21
20b   Medulla K+ rapidly yellow turning red (salazinic acid)       22

21a   Isidia fine; widespread
                         P. conformatum (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 270)
21b   Isidia coarse and breaking open; above 2500 m in northern Andes
                              P. fractum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 292)

22a   Thallus brown below (darkening with age) and finely short 
      rhizinate to the margin; USA - Mexico, Caribbean
                                Canomaculina neotropica (Kurok.) Elix 
      (P. neotropicum Kurok.) (Mycotaxon 5: 437)
22b   Thallus black below with a bare brown marginal zone; widespread
                         P. flavescens (Kremp.) Hale (Hale 1965: 272)

23a (18) Lower surface brown (darkening at the center with age),
      finely short-rhizinate with scattered much longer rhizines to 
      the margin; upper surface distinctly white-maculate, shiny   24
23b   Lower side jet black, sparsely rhizinate with a broad, usually 
      bare, black or brown marginal zone below the lobe tips; upper 
      surface dull                                                 27

24a   Medulla K- or K+ slowly yellowish to brownish                25
24b   Medulla K+ yellow turning red (salazinic acid)               26

25a   Medulla P- (norlobaridone and loxodin); Caribbean & Mexico
                             Canomaculina subtinctoria (Zahlbr.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella subtinctoria (Zahlbr.) Kurok., P. subtinctorium 
      (Zahlbr.) Hale, Canomaculina haitiensis (Hale) Elix = P. 
      haitiense (Hale) Hale) (Hale 1965: 317)
25b   Medulla P+ red (fumarprotocetraric and traces of protocetraric 
      acid); southern Brazil
              Canomaculina fumarprotocetrarica (Marcelli & Hale) Elix 
      (Rimeliella fumarprotocetrarica (Marcelli & Hale) Kurok., P. 
      fumarprotocetraricum Marcelli & Hale) (Mycotaxon 25: 88)

26a   Trace of usnic acid often present in cortex; norlobaridone and 
      loxodin lacking; USA - Mexico, Caribbean
                                Canomaculina neotropica (Kurok.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella neotropica (Kurok.) Kurok., P. neotropicum Kurok.)
26b   Usnic acid lacking; norlobaridone and loxodin present
                             Canomaculina subtinctoria (Zahlbr.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella subtinctoria (Zahlbr.) Kurok., P. subtinctorium 
      (Zahlbr.) Hale) (Hale 1965: 317)

27a (23)   Upper cortex finely reticulately cracked to lobe tips; 
      rhizines rather numerous, usually present till near the margin 
      of the lobe tips, of very unequal length                     28
27b   Upper cortex continuous, cracking irregularly with age in the 
      center of the thallus; rhizines scarce, absent from a broad 
      marginal zone in the lobe tips                               29

28a   Medulla K+ yellow turning red, UV- (salazinic acid); widespread
                     Rimelia subisidiosa (Müll. Arg.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. subisidiosum (Müll. Arg.) Hale)
28b   Medulla K-, UV+ yellow (norlobaridone and lichexanthone); 
      Venezuela                               Rimelia bonplandii Nata

29a   Isidia cylindrical, uniform, mostly unbranched               30
29b   Isidia becoming subsorediate or fatiscent-coralloid and tall or 
      pustulate                                                    35

30a   Medulla K-                                                   31
30b   Medulla K+ yellow or yellow turning red                      32

31a   Medulla UV+ white (alectoronic acid); orange-red medullary 
      pigment usually present in lower part of medulla; saxicolous in 
      pine-oak forest of Mexico-Honduras
                             P. erasmium (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 290)
      (When medulla unpigmented, try also P. mellissii, couplet 37)
31b   Medulla UV- (olivetoric acid); no medullary pigment; Brazil
      (Rio Grande do Sul), on rock                  P. horridum Fleig

32a   Salazinic acid present; medulla C+ or UV+                    33
32b   Stictic acid present; medulla C-, UV-                        34

33a   Medulla C-, UV+ yellow (lichexanthone); North & Central America
                                           P. ultralucens (Krog) Hale
33b   Medulla C+ rose, UV- (gyrophoric acid) 
                                P. concurrens Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 432)

34a   Isidia dense, (partly) ciliate; bare zone below narrow; wide-
      spread               P. crinitum (Ach.) Choisy (Hale 1965: 284)
34b   Isidia dense, not ciliate; bare zone below narrow; widespread?
                      P. internexum (Nyl.) Hale ex DePriest & B. Hale
34c   Fine-lobulate (no true isidia); mangrove southern Brazil
                      P. lobulatum Marcelli & Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 88)

35a   Medulla K+ yellow turning red (salazinic acid) 
                         P. coralliforme (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 324)
35b   Medulla K- or K+ persistently yellow                         36

36a   Isidia tall, fatiscent-coralloid; medulla K+ yellow 
      (atranorin); Guyana, Amazonia
                         P. flavotinctum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 291)
36b   Isidia pustular, not becoming sorediate; medulla K-, P+ orange 
      (protocetraric acid); Parana               P. gibberosum Kurok.
36c   Isidia short, not fatiscent but becoming sorediate or mixed 
      with soredia; medulla K-                                     37

37a   Medulla strongly UV+ white (alectoronic acid); widespread
                           P. mellissii (Dodge) Hale (Hale 1965: 297)
37b   Medulla weakly UV+ pale white or negative (norlobaridone); 
      southern Brazil     P. paulense (Zahlbr.) Hale (Hale 1965: 334)



51a (1) Cilia completely lacking at lobe tips and in the lobe axils
                                                                   52
51b   Cilia well developed around lobe tips to quite sparse and 
      present only in lobe axils                                   67

52a   Medulla pale yellow, at least in lower half, to yellow orange 
      throughout                                                   53
52b   Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decayed plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                       57

53a   Soralia broad and diffuse, mostly submarginal; medulla with 
      gyrophoric acid and entothein; Venezuela - Argentina
                           P. flavomedullosum Hale (Mycotaxon 1: 110)
53b   Soralia narrow, linear, marginal for the most part           54

54a   Medulla P+ red (protocetraric and echinocarpic acids); South 
      America; resembles P. dilatatum, but with pigmented medulla
                                              P. affluens (Hale) Hale
54b   Medulla P-                                                   55

55a   Medulla C+ rose (entothein, gyrophoric acid and lichexanthone 
      in medulla); soralia strictly marginal; Paraguay - Argentina
                                P. conjunctum Hale (Mycotaxon 1: 108)
55b   Medulla C+ yellowish or C-                                   56

56a   Medulla C- or C+ dull yellowish (fatty acid, entothein); cilia 
      may be very sparse; Sao Paulo (Brazil) 
                      P. araucariarum (Zahlbr.) Hale (Hale 1965: 238)
56b   Medulla C- (diffractaic and barbatic acids), pigmented only in 
      lower half; soredia subgranular; Chiapas
                       P. matudae (Kurok.) Hale ex DePriest & B. Hale

57a (52) Medulla K+ yellow turning red                             58
57b   Medulla K- or slowly yellowish                               59

58a   Thallus large and leathery, without pustules; medulla with 
      salazinic acid     P. cristiferum (Tayl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 241)
58b   Thallus smaller, membraneous, with soredia produced on 
      pustules; medulla with stictic acid; Andean
                              P. bangii (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 281)
58c   Thallus smaller, membraneous, without pustules; medulla with 
      norstictic acid; Mexico-Nicaragua, Minas Gerais
                          P. rubifaciens (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 261)

59a   Medulla P+ red (protocetraric acid); cortex often yellowish, 
      with atranorin and usnic acid, or usnic acid alone           60
59b   Medulla P-; cortex grey, with atranorin alone                64

60a   Cortex and/or soralia with usnic acid                        61
60b   Usnic acid completely absent                                 63

61a   Thallus yellowish (no atranorin), membranous; medulla with 
      additionally echinocarpic acid; Amazonia, Guianas
                                 P. aptrootii Aubel (Mycotaxon 44: 3)
61b   Thallus greyish (with atranorin); medulla without echinocarpic 
      acid                                                         62

62a   Soralia yellowish, with usnic acid; lowlands of Caribbean, 
      Central America and Mexico
                         P. dominicanum (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 248)
62b   Thallus membranous; soralia white, on marginal laciniae; 
      highlands, widespread                 P. robustum (Degel.) Hale

63a   Thallus coriaceous, without orange pigment near lower surface; 
      widespread
               P. gardneri (Dodge) Sérus. (Swinscow & Krog 1988: 176)
63b   Thallus membranous; with orange anthraquinone pigment scattered 
      near lower cortex; Para (Brazil) - Guianas, lowlands
                           P. subochraceum Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 117)

64a   Medulla K+ yellowish; always saxicolous P. mordenii (Hale) Hale
64b   Medulla K-; usually corticolous; widespread                  65

65a   Medula C+ red (lecanoric acid) 
                     P. austrosinense (Zahlbr.) Hale (Hale 1965: 238)
65b   Medulla C-                                                   66

66a   Lobes broad (to 10 mm wide); thallus leathery; medulla KC+ 
      rose, UV+ white (alectoronic acid); Uruguay 
                    P. exquisitum (Kurok.) DePriest & B. Hale
66b   Lobes narrower (4-5 mm wide); membranous; medulla KC-, UV- 
      (unknown fatty acids); soralia on top of dactyls; Argentina
                               P. soredioaliphaticum Estrabou & Adler
66c   Lobes narrower (4-5 mm wide); membranous; medulla KC-, UV- 
      (caperatic acid?); soredia not on top of dactyls; widespread 
                       P. praesorediosum (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 258)

67a (51) Medulla orange or pale yellow, especially in lower half   68
67b   Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decayed plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                       69

68a   Pigment pale yellow, mainly in lower half of the medulla, K-; 
      unpigmented medulla C+ rose (gyrophoric acid); West Indies, 
      South America (if pigment K+ purple, see P. sancti-angelii) 
                         P. permutatum (Stirt.) Hale (Hale 1965: 302)
68b   Pigment orange; unpigmented medulla C-, KC+ rose (alectoronic 
      acid); coarsely sorediate or isidiate-sorediate, laminal and 
      submarginal soralia; southern Brazil
                   P. hypomiltoides (Vain.) Hale ex DePriest & B.Hale
      (Hale 1965: 293)

69a   Thallus distinctly yellow to greenish yellow (usnic acid with 
      or without atranorin in the cortex)                          70
69b   Thallus mineral or greenish grey to white (usnic acid lacking 
      in cortex)                                                   75

70a   Soralia coarse, pustular, laminal; cortex breaking apart; 
      occurring on soil and humus in paramo
                              P. fractum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 292)
70b   Soralia round or linear, mostly marginal; cortex entire; 
      usually corticolous in forests, or on rocks                  71

71a   Medulla C+ red (gyrophoric acid); Brazil
                                            P. nylanderi (Lynge) Hale
71b   Medulla C-; known from various countries                     72

72a   Medulla K+ yellow turning red at once (salazinic acid); soralia 
      on more or less involute lobes; pine-oak forest zone in Mexico
                             P. mirandum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 273)
72b   Medulla K- or K+ dull yellowish slowly (protocetraric acid); 
      ciliate mainly in axils; mostly with additionally atranorin in 
      the cortex                                                   73

73a   Thallus weakly yellowish green, atranorin dominant in the 
      cortex; soredia often on marginal lobules; medulla with 
      echinocarpic acids; lowlands, widespread
                                            P. dilatatum (Vain.) Hale
73b   Id., medulla without echinocarpic acid; highlands, widespread
                                            P. robustum (Degel.) Hale
73c   Thallus mostly strongly yellow green, without or with traces of 
      atranorin in cortex; medulla without echinocarpic acid       74

74a   Medulla with malonprotocetraric acid; atranorin absent; Mexico 
      and Caribbean       P. viridiflavum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 274)
74b   Medulla with protocetraric acid alone; atranorin in the cortex; 
      Ecuador-Venezuela, northern Andes at 2400-3500 m. 
                                 P. virescens Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 90)

75a (69) Lower side rhizinate to the margin with fine, short rhizines 
      mixed with long ones; lower side pale brown to black         76
75b   Lower side with a wide, bare marginal zone or with scattered 
      rhizines of very variable length near the margins; lower side 
      dark brown to black, sometimes pale at the margins           82

76a   Lower surface pale brown (sometimes darkening at the center) 77
76b   Lower surface brown to black, at least at the center         80

77a   Medulla UV+ yellow (lichexanthone)                           78
77b   Medulla UV-                                                  79

78a   Soredia mixed with short cilia; norlobaridone absent; southern 
      Brazil                   Canomaculina spinibarbis (Kurok.) Elix 
      (P. spinibarbe (Kurok.) Hale)
78b   Soredia without cilia; norlobaridone present; Venezuela
                              Canomaculina larensis (López Fig.) Elix 
      (P. larense López Fig.) (Phytologia 44: 89)

79a   Medulla with salazinic acid alone; cortex often with additional 
      usnic acid; widespread       Canomaculina subsumpta (Nyl.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella subsumpta (Nyl.) Kurok., P. subsumptum (Nyl.) Hale 
      (Hale 1965: 315)
79b   Medulla with norlobaridone and loxodin, sometimes with 
      salazinic acid; no usnic acid in cortex; widespread; perhaps 
      better included in C. subsumpta? 
                                  Canomaculina conferenda (Hale) Elix 
      (Rimeliella conferenda (Hale) Kurok., P. conferendum Hale) 
      (Mycotaxon 5: 433). Salazinic acid-containing specimens are 
      sometimes separated as Canomaculina reitzii (Hale) Elix = P. 
      reitzii Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 439)

80a   Lower side brown; medulla with salazinic acid; soralia linear 
      on margins; Mexico - Costa Rica, Caribbean, southern Brazil - 
      Argentina                Canomaculina leucosemotheta (Hue) Elix 
      (P. leucosemothetum (Hue) Hale) (Hale 1965: 330)
80b   Lower side black; medulla without salazinic acid             81

81a   Medulla with stictic acid; soralia laminal, round; Mexico, 
      Andes, Argentina     Canomaculina muelleri (Vainio) Elix & Hale
81b   Medulla without lichen substance; Andes, Uruguay
                           Canomaculina pilosa (Stizenb.) Elix & Hale

82a (75) Upper cortex usually distinctly and finely reticulately 
      cracked or reticulately white-maculate (low power 
      magnification); lower side rhizinate till margin with rhizines 
      of very unequal length                                       83
82b   Upper cortex continuous, dull; if maculate, the maculae not 
      reticulately arranged but scattered; lower side with wide, bare 
      marginal, brown or white to mottled zone                     87

83a   Medulla K+ yellow turning red                                84
83b   Medulla K- or K+ slowly dingy yellow                         85

84a   Medulla with salazinic acid alone; common and widespread
                           Rimelia reticulata (Tayl.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. reticulatum (Tayl.) Choisy)
84b   Medulla with norlobaridone and variable amounts of salazinic 
      acid; uncommon      Rimelia commensurata (Hale) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. commensuratum (Hale) Hale)
84c   Medulla with salazinic acid and lichexanthone; Parana
                             Rimelia pontagrossensis Eliasaro & Adler

85a   Medulla P-, KC- (caperatic acid alone)  P. simulans (Hale) Hale
85b   Medula P+ orange or KC+ rose (depsidones present)     86

86a   Medulla P-, KC+ rose (diffractaic acid and lichexanthone); 
      Brazil             Rimelia diffractaica (Essl.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. diffractaicum (Essl.) Hale)
86b   Medulla P-, KC+ rose (norlobaridone); Mexico - Central America 
      only?               Rimelia commensurata (Hale) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. commensuratum (Hale) Hale)
86c   Medulla P+ orange (succinprotocetraric and fumarprotocetraric 
      acids); Brazil - Paraná
                            Rimelia succinreticulata Eliasaro & Adler

87a (82) Lower surface with a broad bare white zone; lobes rather 
      suberect                                                     88
87b   Lower surface light brown to black, rarely with mottled white 
      areas at the margin                                          91

88a   Medulla K-                                                   89
88b   Medulla K+ yellow turning red                                90

89a   Medulla UV+ white, KC+ rose (alectoronic acid) 
                                            P. louisianae (Hale) Hale
89b   Medulla UV- or weak, KC+ rose or KC- (norlobaridone and/or 
      protolichesterinic acid); Mexico - Costa Rica
                         P. hababianum (Gyeln.) Hale (Hale 1965: 325) 
      Norlobaridone-containing specimens are sometimes separated as 
      P. yodae (Kurok.) Hale; (see also C. conferenda)

90a   Stictic acid present in addition to norstictic acid; Mexico
                                        P. hypoleucinum (Stein.) Hale
90b   Stictic acid absent, only norstictic present; Mexico
                           P. hypotropum (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 328)

91a (87) Medulla K+ yellow or yellow turning red at once (salazinic 
      or stictic acids)                                            92
91b   Medulla K- or K+ slowly yellowish                            97

92a   Medulla K+ persistent yellow (stictic acid)                  93
92b   Medulla K+ yellow turning red (salazinic acid)               94

93a   Soralia orbicular on small lobules or submarginal in revolute 
      lobes; hymenium 70-80 mu high; spores 22-30 x 13-16 mu; 
      Caribbean, Mexico-Panama (temperate regions) 
                                     P. chinense (Osbeck) Hale & Ahti 
      (syn. P. perlatum (Huds.) Hale) (Hale 1965: 300)
93b   Soralia diffuse, coarse and pustular ("cortex disintegrating in 
      large areas near the margins and developing into sorediate 
      pustules"; hymenium 70-80 mu high; spores 26-36 x 11-16 mu; 
      Andean                  P. bangii (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 281)

94a   Cortex finely reticulately cracked or reticulately white-
      maculate             Rimelia reticulata (Tayl.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. reticulatum (Tayl.) Choisy)
94b   Cortex continuous; cracked only with age at center           95

95a   Thallus completely divided into 2-7(-12) mm wide, sublinear 
      laciniae; sometimes with traces of gyrophoric and/or 
      protocetraric acid; Mexico - Chile
                            P. paramoreliense W.L. Culb. & C.F. Culb.
95b   Thallus wide-lobes, irregular                                96

96a   Soralia marginal, often linear; cilia usually very sparse and 
      tiny; widespread   P. cristiferum (Tayl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 241)
96b   Soralia submarginal on lobules, orbicular; USA
                          P. margaritatum (Hue) Hale (Hale 1965: 296)
96c   Soralia on top of laciniae; mountains of Mexico - Costa Rica 
      (temperate)           P. stuppeum (Tayl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 308)

97a (91) Medulla P+ red (protocetraric acid)                       98
97b   Medulla P-                                                  102

98a   Soralia pustular, laminal in broad zone; low elevations near 
      Sao Paulo              P. madilynae Fletcher (Mycotaxon 25: 88)
98b   Soralia coarse, (sub)marginal, subfatiscent, mostly on lobules; 
      saxicolous; protocetraric + gyrophoric acids; Parana (Brazil) 
                                P. schindleri Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 89)
98c   Soralia powdery in linear or orbicular marginal groups       99

99a   Protocetraric acid and echinocarpic acid together
                                            P. dilatatum (Vain.) Hale
99b   Protocetraric acid alone present                            100

100a  Cilia conspicuous, 2-3 mm long, distributed around lobe tips; 
      soralia fine; Mexico, southern Brazil
                          P. subarnoldii (Abb.) Hale (Hale 1965: 309)
100b  Cilia shorter, often sparse                                 101

101a  Cilia often sparsely developed, mostly in lobe axils; soredia 
      coarse, on marginal laciniae; widespread in the mountains
                                            P. robustum (Degel.) Hale
101b  Thallus coriaceous; cilia sparse; widespread
               P. gardneri (Dodge) Sérus. (Swinscow & Krog 1988: 176)

102a (97) Medulla C+ rose or red (gyrophoric acid alone); orange- 
      yellow pigment (rhodophyscin) sometimes present near the lower  
      cortex, K+ purple (if pigment K-, see P. permutatum); conidia
      weakly sublageniform (6-8 x 1 mu); widespread
                      P. sancti-angelii (Lynge) Hale (Hale 1965: 306)
102b  Medulla C+ rose (gyrophoric acid and norlobaridone); no pigment
      in medulla; conidia filiform; India, SE Brazil
                                     P. indicum Hale (Hale 1977: 436)
102c  Medulla C-                                                  103

103a  Medulla KC-, UV- (no alectoronic acid)                      104
103b  Medulla KC+ red or rose, UV+ white (alectoronic and/or a-
      collatolic acid)                                            105

104a  Saxicolous; with protolichesterinic acid; resembling 
      P. praesorediosum but ciliate; widespread
                              P. grayanum (Hue) Hale (Hale 1965: 292)
104b  Corticolous; with constipatic acid; Para (Brazil) 
                             P. ciliiferum Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 112)

105a  Lobes rather narrow and laciniate; soralia mostly orbicular on 
      the laciniae, some marginal; marginal zone below narrow, mostly 
      black; Caribbean, Mexico-Guatemala (+ temperate areas) 
                               P. arnoldii (DR) Hale (Hale 1965: 279)
105b  Lobes broader, not laciniate; soralia linear and marginal: bare 
      zone below broad, brown                                     106

106a  Soredia intermixed with isidia and cilia; widespread
                           P. mellissii (Dodge) Hale (Hale 1965: 297)
106b  Soredia without isidial initials or cilia intermingled      107

107a  Soralia not pustular, linear; medulla often with skyrin; on 
      trees; cilia 3-6 mm long; widespread
                          P. rampoddense (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 304)
107b  Pustulate-sorediate along margins; saxicolous; cilia 2-4 mm 
      long; Venezuelan Andes  P. sorediiferum Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 89)



121a (1) Cilia completely lacking around lobe tips and in lobe axils
                                                                  122
121b  Cilia well developed around lobe tips to quite sparse and 
      present only in lobe axils                                  136

122a  Medulla yellow or yellow orange throughout or for the most 
      part, and especially in the apothecial amphithecium         123
122b  Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decayed plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                      125

123a  Medulla pale orange to salmon red, P+ red (protocetraric acid); 
      apothecia imperforate; hymenium 75-80 mu high; spores 22-24 x 
      11-12 mu; Venezuelan Andes  P. betaniae Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 87)
123b  Medulla P-                                                  124

124a  Medulla yellow-orange, C+ red (gyrophoric acid); spores 
      unknown; widespread   P. crocoides (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 244)
124b  Medulla pale yellow, C+ yellow-orange (barbatic and obtusatic 
      acids, entothein); spores 21-26 x 9-13 mu; Mexico (Chiapas 
      1000 m.)            P. myelochroum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 256)

125a  Medulla C+ blood red (lecanoric acid); apothecia if present 
      perforate         P. andinum (Müll. Arg.) Hale (Hale 1965: 236)
125b  Medulla C-; apothecia if present imperforate                126

126a  Medulla P-                                                  127
126b  Medulla P+ red or orange                                    128

127a  Caperatic acid present; hymenium 60-90 mu high; spores to 15-21 
      x 7-11 mu long; Mexico-Guatemala, Bolivia-Uruguay-Mato Grosso
                     P. mesotropum (Müll. Arg.) Hale (Hale 1965: 255)
127b  Diffractaic and barbatic acid present; hymenium 100-130 mu 
      high; spores 21-30 x 10-15 mu; Mexico, Caribbean; medulla 
      sometimes orange near lower cortex
                            P. mesogenes (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 254)

128a  Medulla K+ yellow turning red (salazinic and/or norstictic 
      acid)                                                       129
128b  Medulla K- or faint yellow (protocetraric acid)             131

129a  Salazinic acid alone present; hymenium 100-120 mu high; spores 
      28-32 x 14-16 mu; widespread
                            P. latissimum (Fée) Hale (Hale 1965: 253)
129b  As 129a, but thallus lobes deeply laciniate (apothecia unknown); 
      Mexico                    P. acutatum Kurok. (Kurokawa 2001: 3)
129c  Additional medullary substances present (TLC); hymenium under 
      80 mu high; spores under 25 mu long; South America only     130

130a  Norstictic and salazinic acid present; hymenium 80-90 mu high; 
      spores 20-25 x 10-12 mu; Guyana - southern Brazil
                        P. crassescens (Stirt.) Hale (Hale 1965: 240)
130b  Norstictic and echinocarpic acid present; spores 20-22 x 14 mu; 
      Mato Grosso, Brazil
                       P. wrightii Ferraro & Elix (Mycotaxon 49: 405)

131a  Thallus on rock only; spores up to 15 mu long               132
131b  Thallus on bark, occasionally on rock; spores over 15 mu long
                                                                  133

132a  Thallus rather closely adnate on rocks; hymenium 70-80 mu high; 
      spores 11-14 x 5-7 mu; Central America
                             P. eborinum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 249)
132b  Thallus laciniate, less closely adnate, on rock; hymenium 50-60 
      mu high; spores 12-15 x 5-6 mu; Brazil, Colombia
                  P. blanchetianum (Müll. Arg.) Hale (Hale 1965: 281)

133a  Lobes with long marginal laciniae; hymenium 90-100 mu high; 
      spores 16-21 x 8-10 mu; Mexico (+ Africa) 
                            P. disparile (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 247)
133b  Like 133a, but thallus surface not maculate or finally 
      cracked, and apothecia perforate instead of imperforate; 
      Mexico                  P. cornigerum Kurok. (Kurokawa 2001: 4)
133c  Lobes without conspicuous laciniae                          134

134a  Protocetraric acid alone present, no pigment near lower cortex; 
      hymenium 70-80 mu high; spores 18-22 x 7-10 mu; widespread
      (divided by Elix (1998) into P. zollingeri s.str., with 
      fumarprotocetraric and succinprotocetraric acid, P. overeemii 
      (Zahlbr.) Elix, with protocetraric acid and slightly larger 
      spores, and P. platyphyllinum (Vain.) Elix, with protocetraric
      acid and butlerin derivatives; it is unknown which occur in the
      Neotropics)          P. zollingeri (Hepp) Hale (Hale 1965: 267)
134b  With additionally usnic acid in the cortex, but no pigment near
      lower cortex; spores 16-18 x 10 mu; Andes of Peru 
                                            P. machupicchuense Kurok.
134c  With additionally echinocarpic acid or pigment near lower 
      cortex; South America only                                  135

135a  Orange anthraquinone pigment scattered near lower cortex; 
      hymenium 60-65 mu high; spores 30-33 x 15-18 mu; Para (Brazil) 
                           P. cachimboense Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 110)
135b  Echinocarpic acid present with protocetraric acid; hymenium 100 
      mu high; spores 20-22 x 10 mu; Amazonia (related to P. 
      dilatatum)                  P. progenes Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 438)

136a (121) Medulla yellow or yellow orange throughout or for the most 
      part, and especially in the apothecial amphithecium         137
136b  Medulla white (sometimes with patches of orange-red skyrin or 
      other anthraquinones near lower cortex; in decayed plants 
      salazinic acid may cause red staining)                      142

137a  Thallus distinctly yellowish green (usnic acid + atranorin in 
      cortex, protocetraric acid and entothein in medulla); cilia 
      scarce; apothecia eciliate; hymenium 70-80 mu high; spores 25-
      27 x 12-13 mu; Venezuelan Andes
                                   P. lopezii Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 437)
137b  Thallus mineral, greenish or whitish grey (usnic acid lacking) 
                                                                  138

138a  Medulla P+ red (protocetraric acid, entothein); laciniate; 
      apothecia ciliate; Amazonia, Venezuela P. cristatum (Nyl.) Hale
138b  Medulla P-                                                  139

139a  Cortex fragile, breaking apart; medulla pale yellow; fatty acid 
      in medulla; apothecia imperforate; hymenium 80-95 mu high; 
      spores 22-27 x 10-12 mu; southern Brazil
                                    P. cryptoxanthoides (Kurok.) Hale
139b  Cortex entire; medulla more deeply pigmented                140

140a  Medulla bright lemon yellow (vulpinic acid alone); southern 
      Brazil                P. cornutum (Lynge) Hale (Hale 1965: 283)
140b  Medulla lighter yellow                                      141

141a  Medulla lighter yellow, reddish below (entothein and 
      rhodophyscin); southern Brazil      P. lyngeanum (Zahlbr.) Hale
141b  Medulla lighter yellow above, orange-red below (entothein and 
      barbatic acid); apothecia ciliate; not yet known from the 
      Neotropics                         P. appendiculatum (Fée) Hale

142a (136) Thallus yellowish green (usnic acid in cortex)         143
142b  Thallus mineral to whitish grey (usnic acid lacking)        144

143a  Thallus often white-pruinose; medulla with salazinic (and 
      gyrophoric?) acid; saxicolous; southern Brazil - Uruguay
                         P. delicatulum (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 271)
143b  Thallus not pruinose; medulla with salazinic acid and unknown 
      substance Q; corticolous; Corrientes (Argentina)
                                       P. masonii Ferraro (1979: 193)

144a  Lower surface to the margin covered with fine rhizines, mixed 
      with scattered, much longer rhizines, usually pale to brown,
      often darkening at the center with age, sometimes completely
      black; upper side maculate                                  145
144b  Lower surface bare or with sparse, long rhizines (dense in 
      Rimelia), mostly with a jet black center, the marginal zone 
      whitish or light brown to black; upper side maculate or
      not maculate                                                148

145a  Medulla K+ yellow turning red (salazinic acid)              146
145b  Medulla K-; cortex with atranorin only (salazinic acid absent);
      southern Brazil - Argentina
                                  Canomaculina recipienda (Nyl.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella recipenda (Nyl.) Kurok., P. recipiendum (Nyl.) 
      Hale) (Hale 1965: 314)

146a  Short rhizines sparsely branched and somewhat intricate; 
      apothecia ciliate; thallus not laciniate; lower surface mostly 
      pale brown, darkening only in the center; norlobaridone absent;
      Uruguay-Argentina         Canomaculina uruguensis (Kremp.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella uruguensis (Kremp.) Kurok., P. uruguense (Kremp.) 
      Hale) (Hale 1965: 342)
146b  Short rhizines sparsely branched and somewhat intricate;
      apothecia not ciliate; thallus laciniate with convex laciniae;
      lower side black; norlobaridone absent; NW Argentina
                               Canomaculina laciniella Ferraro & Elix
146c  Short rhizines simple; apothecia not ciliate; thallus laciniate
      or not; lower side mostly pale brown; norlobaridone sometimes
      present                                                     147

147a  Thallus not laciniate; southern Brazil
                            Canomaculina subcaperata (Krempelh.) Elix 
      (Rimeliella subcaperata (Krempelh.) Kurok., P. subcaperatum 
      (Kremp.) Hale) (Hale 1965: 314)
147b  Thallus laciniate, lacinia flat; Argentina - Bolivia
                 Canomaculina cristobalii (L. I. Ferraro & Elix) Elix 
      (Rimeliella cristobalii L. I. Ferraro & Elix) (Mycotaxon 49: 
      406)

148a (144) Lower surface with a distinct, broad, bare, white or ivory 
      to brown rim; lobes often suberect                          149
148b  Lower surface with a brown or black, bare or rhizinate rim (or 
      at most somewhat white-mottled); lobes often more adnate, not 
      suberect                                                    160

149a  Medulla K+ yellow turning orange or red (norstictic, stictic or
      salazinic acid)                                             150
149b  Medulla K-                                                  152

150a  Medulla K+ yellow (stictic acid); apothecia if present 
      perforate; rim below often mottled white; hymenium 120-150 mu 
      high; spores 23-30 x 12-18 mu; Mexico-Guatemala, Caribbean,  
      southern Brazil (if thallus applanate, marginally rhizinate and  
      with norsticticacid, cf. Parmotremopsis phlyctina (Hale) Elix & 
      Hale)                 P. eciliatum (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 289)
150b  Medulla K-; apothecia if present imperforate                151

151a  Norstictic acid alone present; Jamaica, USA
                          P. perforatum (Jacq.) Hale (Hale 1965: 335)
151b  Norstictic acid present with alectoronic acid; southeastern USA
                                P. subrigidum Egan (Egan et al. 2005)
151c  Stictic acid present with norstictic acid
                                        P. preperforatum (Culb.) Hale
151d  Salazinic acid present; thallus often laciniate; Mexico 600-900 
      m.                                            P. arteagrum Egan

152a  Apothecia if present perforate; spores less than 20 mu long 
      (except P. glaucocarpoides)                                 153
152b  Apothecia if present imperforate; spores usually more than 20 
      mu long                                                     157

153a  Medulla UV+ white (alectoronic acid present)                154
153b  Medulla UV- (alectoronic absent)                            155

154a  Thallus maculate; apothecium rim rarely ciliate; southern 
      Brazil - Argentina     P. rigidum (Lynge) Hale (Hale 1965: 338)
      similar to P. subrigidum, but ascospores 18-33 x 9-19 mu 
      instead of 9-15 x 5-9 mu, pycnoconidia usually <12 mu instead
      of 11-20 mu, absence of norstictic acid and regular presence of
      a-collatolic acid (Egan et al. 2005); norstictic acid-deficient
      P. subrigidum may key out here and can be distinguished by 
      ascospores and pycnoconidia.
154b  Thallus not maculate; apothecium rim ciliate; Mexico
                                P. wirthii Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 118)

155a  Medulla C+ red (gyrophoric, fatty acids); maculate; Brazil (+
      Africa)                    P. hanningtonianum (Müll. Arg.) Hale
155b  Medulla C- (gyrophoric acid absent)                         156

156a  Norlobaridone present (UV negative or weak), and/or 
      protolichesterinic acid; spores 15-20 x 8-10 mu; Mexico?, 
      Africa            P. abessinicum (Kremp.) Hale (Hale 1965: 320)
156b  Fatty acid present only (UV-); spores 25-30 x 12-15 mu; Africa, 
      neotropical?                  P. glaucocarpoides (Zahlbr.) Hale

157a (152) Medulla C+ red (gyrophoric acid); hymenium 130-150 mu  
      high; spores 24-28 x 14-16 mu; southern Brazil
                                 P. catarinae Hale (Mycotaxon 25: 87)
157b  Medulla C- (gyrophoric acid absent)                         158

158a  Medulla KC-, UV. (protolichesterinic acid); apothecia ciliate, 
      with maculate amphithecium; hymenium 80-100 mu high; spores 20-
      26 x 10-16 mu; southern Brazil
                         P. melanothrix (Mont.) Hale (Hale 1965: 332)
158b  Medulla KC+ rose, UV+ white (alectoronic acid); rim below 
      uniformly white; exciple often short-dentate and ciliate    159

159a  Hymenium 100-140 mu high; spores 26-34 x 12-18 mu; medulla with 
      orange skyrin pigment scattered near lower cortex; surface 
      maculate; Mexico - Guatemala, Caribbean, southern Brazil - 
      Argentina          P. subrugatum (Kremp.) Hale (Hale 1965: 341)
159b  Hymenium 50-70 mu high; spores 11-22 x 6-12 mu; widespread
                         P. argentinum (Kremp.) Hale (Hale 1965: 322)

160a (148) Lower side rhizinate below to the margin, with rhizines of 
      very unequal length; cortex finely reticulately cracked or 
      white-maculate                                              161
160b  Lower side rhizinate below to margin, with short rhizines; 
      upper side heavily maculate; thallus applanate; no substances 
      in medulla; spores 14-19 x 8-12 mu; southern Brazil to 
      Argentina               Canomaculina consors (Nyl.) Elix & Hale
160c  Lower side sparsely rhizinate, with wide, bare marginal zone in 
      lobe tips; cortex mostly continuous or irregularly cracked with 
      age toward thallus center                                   163

161a  Medulla K+ yellow turning red, UV- (salazinic acid); lobes often 
      laciniate (cf. P. ruptum (Lynge) Hale ex DePriest & B. Hale, 
      see below); widespread   Rimelia cetrata (Ach.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. cetratum (Ach.) Hale)
161b  Medulla K+ yellow turning red, UV+ yellow (salazinic acid and 
      lichexanthone); upper surface faintly maculate; apothecia 
      perforate; spores 14.5-16 x 10-11 mu; Minas Gerais
                                 P. lichexanthonicum Eliasaro & Adler
161c  Medulla K-                                                  162

162a  Caperatic acid present; SE Brazil only?
                           Rimelia macrocarpa (Pers.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. macrocarpum (Pers.) Hale)
162b  Norlobaridone and loxodin present; SE Brazil only?
                              Rimelia homotoma (Nyl.) Hale & Fletcher 
      (P. homotomum (Nyl.) Hale)

163a (160) Medulla K+ yellow turning orange or red (stictic or 
      salazinic acid)                                             164
163b  Medulla K-                                                  170

164a  Apothecia perforate, at least partly                        165
164b  Apothecia imperforate                                       166
164c  Apothecia unknown                                           169

165a  Lobes rounded, 8-10 mm wide, membranaceous, in the center often
      laciniate with many pycnidia; cilia 1.5-5 m long; spores 14-16 
      x 7-9 mu; oak-pine zone of Mexico, USA, Brazil
                             P. eurysacum (Hue) Hale (Hale 1965: 290)
165b  As 165a, but lobes coriaceous, in the center crenate; cilia 
      1-3 mm long, rare; spores 10-14 x 6-10 mu; SE USA to Mexico
                               P. despectum Kurok. (Kurokawa 2001: 5)
165c  As 165b, but upper surface strongly maculate, reticulately 
      cracked in older lobes, and lower side sometimes slightly 
      papillate             P. permaculatum Kurok. (Kurokawa 2001: 8)
165d  Lobes linear-elongate, 2-5(-10) mm wide, completely laciniate; 
      spores 16-20 x 8-10 mu; Mexico 2250-3300 m. 
                      P. moreliense (B. de Lesd.) W. Culb. & C. Culb.
165e  If lichexanthone present in medulla (UV+ yellow), see P. 
      lichexanthonicum above

166a  Upper cortex reticulately white maculate to cracked; 
      not laciniate, with narrow bare marginal zone below; salazinic 
      acid; apothecia eciliate; hymenium 60-70 mu high; spores 16-18 
      x 9 mu; Costa Rica - Panama, southern Brazil-Paraguay
      (intermediate with Rimelia; syn. P. expansum Hale, Mycotaxon 5: 
      435)               P. ruptum (Lynge) Hale ex DePriest & B. Hale
166b  Upper cortex continuous or cracked with age toward the thallus 
      center; spores more than 20 mu long                         167

167a  Cilia sparse, only in lobe axils; salazinic acid present
                            P. latissimum (Fée) Hale (Hale 1965: 253)
167b  Cilia usually conspicuous around lobe tips; stictic acid 
      present                                                     168

168a  Corticolous; cilia fine; stictic acid; hymenium 120-150 mu 
      high; spores 23-30 x 12-18 mu; Mexico-Guatemala, Caribbean, 
      southern Brazil       P. eciliatum (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 289)
168b  Lobulate, stictic acid; mangrove of southern Brazil
                                         P. lobulatum Marcelli & Hale

169a  Thallus with scattered ciliate warts; Guyana Highland
                           P. verrucisetosum Sipman (Mycotaxon 44: 8)
169b  Lobes very wide, 10-20 mm; southern Brazil
                        P. mantiqueirensis Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 113)

170a (163) Medulla C+ red; hymenium over (80-)90 mu high; spores 24-
      35 mu long                                                  171
170b  Medulla C-; hymenium and spores various                     173

171a  Apothecia perforate; gyrophoric acid present; thallus 
      coriaceous; hymenium 60-80 mu high; spores 18-26 x 7-12 mu; 
      Caribbean, elsewhere? P. eunetum (Stirt.) Hale (Hale 1965: 325)
171b  Apothecia imperforate; hymenium over (80-)90 mu high; spores 
      24-35 mu long                                               172

172a  Olivetoric acid present; southern Brazil
                              P. abnuens (Nyl.) Hale (Hale 1965: 277)
172b  Gyrophoric and lecanoric acids present; Guianas
                               P. gradsteinii Aubel (Mycotaxon 44: 6)

173a  Medulla UV+ white (alectoronic acid present); apothecia 
      perforate or imperforate                                    174
173b  Medulla UV-; apothecia imperforate                          179

174a  Apothecia perforate                                         175
174b  Apothecia imperforate                                       178

175a  Orange pigment (skyrin) scattered in medulla near lower 
      surface; thallus papery                                     176
175b  Orange pigment completely absent; thallus coriaceous        177

176a  Thallus papery, maculate; apothecia pedicellate, with eciliate 
      rim; hymenium 70-80 mu high; spores 17-22 x 9-12 mu; Mexico - 
      Guatemala             P. chiapense (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 323)
176b  Apothecia perforate (to imperforate); lobes becoming short 
      laciniate-lobulate; hymenium ca. 60 mu high; spores 14-15 x 6 
      mu; southern Brazil   P. brasiliense Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 109)

177a  Pycnoconidia sublageniform, 6-7 mu long; thallus coriaceous; 
      apothecia substipitate; hymenium 50-70 mu high; spores 12-17 x 
      7-10 mu; cilia sparse; Brazil, elsewhere? 
          P. maclayanum (Müll. Arg.) Hale (Swinscow & Krog 1988: 183) 
      [incl. P. breviciliatum (Hale) Hale (Hale 1965: 282)]
177b  Pycnoconidia filiform, 8-11 mu long; spores 13-18 x 10-14 mu; 
      otherwise as a; Argentina
                            P. pseudobreviciliatum Adler, Elix & Hale

178a  Thallus rather fragile, marginal cilia 2-5 mm long; medulla 
      sometimes with skyrin; apothecia ciliate; hymenium 75-90 mu 
      high; spores 17-22 x 6-10 mu; southern Brazil
                             P. wainii (A. Sm.) Hale (Hale 1965: 313)
178b  Thallus not fragile, marginal cilia 0.5-1.5 mm; medulla with 
      scattered orange skyrin pigment near lower cortex; apothecia 
      ciliate; hymenium 85-90 mu high; spores 28-30 x 10-15 mu; 
      southern Brazil          P. maraense Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 114)

179a  Medulla P- (protocetraric acid absent, fatty acids present); 
      apothecia estipitate, rarely perforate, not ciliate; hymenium 
      60-70 mu high; spores 22-25 x 10-12 mu; Para (Brazil) 
                               P. paraense Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 116)
179b  Medulla P+ red (protocetraric acid)                         180

180a  Lobes broad and rotund, without conspicuous laciniae; cilia 
      very sparse, in axils only, absent on tips; widespread; see 
      note under 134a                       P. zollingeri (Hepp) Hale
180b  Lobes more or less marginally dissected and laciniate; cilia 
      present in axils and on lobe tips, sometimes sparse         181

181a  Anthraquinone pigment scattered in medulla near lower cortex; 
      apothecia not ciliate; hymenium 60-65 mu high               182
181b  Anthraquinone pigment absent; apothecia sometimes ciliate; 
      hymenium usually over 90 mu high                            183

182a  Thallus not laciniate, lobes 2-4 mm wide; apothecia with 
      inrolled rim; hymenium 60-65 mu high; spores 24-27 x 15-18 mu; 
      Brazil (Mato Grosso)     P. confusum Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 113)
182b  Thallus laciniate, lobes 5-9 mm wide; hymenium 60-65 mu high; 
      spores 28-30 x 10-12 mu; Brazil (Para) 
                            P. pigmentosum Hale (Bibl. Lich. 38: 116)

183a  Echinocarpic acid present with protocetraric acid; apothecia 
      not ciliate; hymenium 100 mu high; spores 20-22 x 10 mu; 
      Amazonia (related to P. dilatatum) 
                                  P. progenes Hale (Mycotaxon 5: 438)
183b  Echinocarpic acid absent; lobes marginally dissected and 
      laciniate                                                   184

184a  Spores less than 20 mu; North America
                           P. submarginale (Michx.) DePriest & B.Hale
      (syn. P. michauxianum (Zahlbr.) Hale)
184b  Spores 26-34 x 12-16 mu; hymenium 90-110 mu; apothecium exciple 
      dentate-laciniate, ciliate; Bolivia, elsewhere? 
                           P. merrillii (Vain.) Hale (Hale 1965: 298)


Literature:
Adler, M. T. 1989. Two new species in Parmeliaceae (Lichenized Ascomycotina) and new records for Argentina. Mycotaxon 35: 399-404.
Culberson, W. L. & Culberson, C. F. 1981. The genera Cetrariastrum and Concamerella (Parmeliaceae): A chemosystematic synopsis. Bryologist 84: 273-314.
DePriest, P. & Hale, B. W. 1998. New combinations in parmelioid genera (Ascomycotina: Parmeliaceae). Mycotaxon 67: 201-206.
Egan, R. S. 1982. Parmotrema arteagum, a new lichen species from Mexico. Bryologist 85: 79-83.
Egan, R. S., Harms, R. & Widhelm, T. 2005. Studies on the lichen Parmotrema rigidum s. lat. from North and South America. Bryologist 108: 402-405.
Eliasaro, S. & Adler, M. T. 1997. Two new species and new reports in the Parmeliaceae sensu stricto (lichenized ascomycotina) from Brazil. Mycotaxon 63: 49-55.
Eliasaro, S. & Adler, M. T. 1998. Rimelia pontagrossensis, a new species in the Parmeliaceae sensu stricto (lichenized ascomycotina) from Brazil. Mycotaxon 66: 127-130.
Elix, J. A. 1997. The lichen genera Canomaculina and Rimeliella (Ascomycotina, Parmeliaceae). Mycotaxon 65: 475-479.
Elix, J. A. 1998. Clarification of the synonymy and chemistry of Parmotrema zollingeri and related species. Australasian Lichenology 42: 22-27.
Estrabou, C. & Adler, M. T. 1998. Two new species of Parmotrema (Parmeliaceae sensu stricto, lichenized ascomycotina) from Argentina. Mycotaxon 66: 131-136.
Farr, E. R., Hale, B. C. & DePriest, P. T. (1999). Parmeliaceae: Searchable List of Names in the Parmelioid Genera (Lichens). http://persoon.si.edu/parmeliaceae/ (30 September 1999)
Ferraro, L. I. 1979. Una nueva especie de Parmeliaceae para el NE. Argentino. Hickenia 1(34): 191-193.
Ferraro, L. I. & Elix, J. A. 1993. Two new species of Parmeliaceae (Lichenized Ascomycotina) from South America. Mycotaxon 49: 405-409.
Ferraro, L. I. & Elix, J. A. 2000. A new species of Canomaculina (Lichenized Ascomycotina) from Argentina. Mycotaxon 74(2): 4391-394.
Fleig, M. 1999. New species in the lichen genus Parmotrema (Parmeliaceae Ascomycotina) from southern Brazil. Mycotaxon 71: 199-206.
Hale, M. E. 1965. A monograph of Parmelia subgenus Amphigymnia. Contrib. US Nat. Museum 36 (5): 193-358.
Hale, M. E. 1974. Notes on species of Parmotrema (Lichenes: Parmeliaceae) containing yellow pigments. Mycotaxon 1: 105-116.
Hale, M. E. 1976. A monograph of the lichen genus Parmelina Hale (Parmeliaceae). Smithsonian Contrib. Bot. 33: 1-60.
Hale, M. E. 1977. New species in the lichen genus Parmotrema Mass. Mycotaxon 5: 432-448.
Hale, M. E. 1986. New species in the lichen family Parmeliaceae (Ascomycotina). Mycotaxon 25: 85-93.
Hale, M. E. 1990. New species of Parmotrema (Ascomycotina: Parmeliaceae) from Tropical America. Bibl. Lichenol. 38: 109-110.
Kurokawa, S. 1984. Joint occurrence of diffractaic and barbatic acids in Parmelia, subgenus Amphigymnia (Lichenes). Journ. Jap. Bot. 59: 193-198.
Kurokawa, S. & Moon, H.-H. 1998. Three new species and a new combination in Parmotrema (Parmeliaceae). Bull. Bot. Gard. Toyama 3: 17-23.
Kurokawa, S. 2001. Taxonomic Notes on Parmelia reparata (Parmeliaceae, Lichenes) and the Related Species. Bull. Natn. Sci. Mus., Tokyo, Ser. B, 27 (1): 1-10.
Sipman, H. & Aubel, R. J. M. T. van, 1992. New Parmeliaceae (lichenes) from the Guianas and surroundings. Mycotaxon 44: 1-12.
Swinscow, T. D. V. & Krog, H. 1988. Macrolichens of East Africa. British Museum (Natural History), London. 390 pp.


BGBM homepage BGBM research homepage more keys

© Botanischer Garten und Botanisches Museum Berlin-Dahlem, Freie Universität Berlin
page editor: Harrie Sipman, imprint
http://www.bgbm.org/sipman/keys/Neoparmo.htm